President Obama gave the American people and Congress a politically calculated call to action last night that was many things: just non-controversial enough to put real pressure on Republicans to go along, just concrete enough to forestall major criticism, and workable on the margin to improve the economy in a minor way.
This was a successful speech for the president. In some respects it was the same old rehashed proposals, but they went a bit further in areas such as hiring the long-term unemployed and offering more payroll tax cuts than we've seen before.
And Republicans are feeling the pressure to go along. So I do expect the payroll taxes to pass in some similar form.
Let's talk about what was more controversial: paying for the plan. The president promised to offset the expense with savings that the congressional supercommittee on the debt could identify. This is a half measure that really does not quite pay for itself yet, but it's enough for the American people to accept, and in this sense, the president will get a pass for this approach. Obama promised a more concrete proposal later in September. I heard a lot of questioning about why he didn't provide the specifics last night, but it seems like a shrewd move to me.
By parsing the specifics out Obama does a few things. He calls for immediate action on the non-controversial payroll tax, which has a chance for passing. He also puts immediate pressure on Congress while buying time for more specifics. And he guarantees his proposals can not just be rejected out of hand - the country and Congress must tune in for weeks into where Obama wants to lead this country. And we were all just about to start tuning out.
These are campaign moves. But if it takes a campaign to get real proposals from our politicians, than I guess campaigns are a good thing.